I have been printing with my Epson P6000 Piezography Pro Ink set for years. I have profiled several gloss and matte papers and all of them are printing just fine.
I’m trying to profile the Red River Aurora Art White 300. When I print the 52 Step ColorMunki target is where I’m having issues. I have tried several different paper profiles and get the same results. After the 4th or 5th black step the ink does not seem to cover the step with a solid color. When I print on Canson Arches 88 paper all is good. I have tried to increase the density in the Print Tool setting, but still have same issue. I can see the same issue if i print an image. When i look through a loop I can the that some areas dont have ink. Any idea how to resolve.
Please take a photo of the target so I can see what you are seeing.
Please print the inksep target in QTR Calibration Mode on the same paper and send a photo. You will find inseparation8.tif in QuadToneRIP / CurveDesign / Images. Print it with No Color Management.
This way I can learn more about the ink or inks that are not printing as expected.
I got another paper from Red River Polar Matte 330 thinking that it might work with a QTR paper profile as a starting point like I have done in the past, but that does not seem to be the case. The Red River Aurora Art White 300 is cotton and the Red River Polar Matte 330 is cellulose. From how they have been printing I think the coating is the same or very close.
I printed the inksep target in QTR Calibration Mode at 100%, 50% and 45%. At the 100% I can see that at 50 there is a strange pattern on all colors at this point. When I print the inksep target at 45% this strange pattern appears at 75 on all colors at this point. When I print the inksep target at 50% this strange pattern appears at 100 on all colors at this point. When I use a loop looking at the 100% target I can see at 0 to 45 the coverage is even and looks to cover the whole block. Above 50 it seems that each block has a molton pattern to it and has lighter and darker areas. Not sure if this could be the paper swelling and the platen gap not wide enough, to much ink. Printer platen gap is set to ‘Wider’ as this paper is 15mil think.
I have printed the Color Munki 51 Step target at different ink limits of 40, 60, 75,77, 80. Only at about 77 or above does it look like there is the right amount of ink density on the paper.
If you look at the last image of the Moab Lasal profile where I varied the ink limit in the Piezography Pro toolyou can see where the ink is not smooth.
Any and all assistance would be greatly appreciated.
Are you sure that the pattern you are seeing are not Mach bands? That’s a famous optical illusion where the human brain artificially exaggerates the contrast right at the border where two different shades of gray meet. Unless you are seeing something not related to that, this is purely lateral inhibition which allows humans to boost contrast and identify objects that might have otherwise creeped up on and ate us.
I think that if you cut out each step and place it by itself on a white background that the “pattern” you are seeing will not be there.
So I’m trying another Red River paper, Polar matte. I’m trying to profile the paper. After my first scan of the target,I put the numbers into Pro Tool and printed the target again. With this print I’m getting a strange pattern in just one of the 51 blocks. It happens in both cool and warm, but in different places. When I measure and print a 2nd scan the strange pattern moves. In the case of cool it moved one block with warm it was like 5 blocks. Is it possible the paper is getting to much ink. See the block with red triangle.
Trouble shooting issues on a specific grade of paper is not terribly difficult.
Print the target on Red River immediately followed by a high ink load paper such as Hahnemuhle Photo Rag, and then a third time back on the Red River.
If you have a paper coating issue, the problem would not persist on the Hahnemuhle.
To verify print the target on Photo Rag followed by Red River and then Photo Rag again. if the problem is only on Red River you have verified that you have a coating issue and probably not worth the time and expense you are throwing at this particular grade.
Polar Matte is a wood pulp based paper with an optically brightened coating. It is very similar to EPSON Ultra Premium Presentation Matte paper which is branded as an extremely high quality paper for office presentations of graphics and photos. Polar Matte fits that same category. Neither is considered to be museum grade archival because the coatings tend to yellow with exposure to light. However, the EPSON prints exceptionally well and apparently you are not getting very good printed results on the Polar.
It may be that Polar cannot take a high ink load at that gray value because multiple inks are crossing over. Unless you print photos with large flat areas of tone I would not think that after profiling you will see these defects in your work.
I’m still profiling. I’m now starting with a uncoated profiles that Walker made a ways back. They are limited to 50% except for Black which is at 100%. I will let you know how it turns out. The initial prints look promising.
I want to confirm I’m not making a mistake. I have to flip channels Y and LLK.
I know with the starting profile I will flip the channels in PPE. Then I scan the starting target. Then I put the starting profile and the measurements into PPE. Do I still flip the channels or put them back so no channels are flipped.
Once you have remapped the Y and LLK channels which creates a New Curve from the curve you pasted into the STARTING CURVE tab (in this example saving the new curve as FlippedNewCurve.quad):
Return the New Channel Remapping to defaults, or close and do not save PPET.
When you linearize, copy and paste the values in FlippedNewCurve.quad into the STARTING CURVE tab.
Enter your measurements into MEASUREMENTS tab.
Copy the data from NEW CURVE as your new curve.
A tip: Once you have remapped one curve, you can copy any other curve into STARTING CURVE and it will create a new curve from it in NEW CURVE. This way you can remap an entire library quickly.
I was able to get good linear curves for Cool and Warm stating with the uncoated curves. So, I was problems with the prints going from almost linear to being worse. I finally figured out the problem. I was doing my profiles on a Windows 11 PC. The max length of the file name and folders combined is like 256 characters. I was saving files in sub, sub folders, etc, when I saved a file I did not get any error about the length it just did not save the file. So when I went to the next scan I was using old data as I copy files from scan 1 into scan 2 folder and update the files. So, make sure when your saving profiles they are actually saving. Also Quad Tone RIP file name max length is 39 characters.
Now I need to understand why the same file in QTR is darker than the Piezo Driver print, that will be another message.
That’s good news you’ve solved it! Those persnickety errors can be hard to trace. But often it’s the most unobvious obvious that trips things up.
No need to write another message or start a new thread! Here you are…
While a .quad file can be split into individual ink channel data, converting those channels to Gutenprint XML files will not produce identical prints. The two drivers use entirely different linearizations, tone-scale curves, and dither (dot-placement) engines. Even if both systems send the same total ink to a pixel, Gutenprint places the dots differently on paper, resulting in distinct dot gain and visual density.
To get the XML driver to match QTR, the driver would need to be fully re-linearized from scratch using a spectrophotometer - physically printing uncorrected target patches, measuring ink densities, and manually writing compensating curves into the XML structure. Furthermore, Gutenprint operates on an RGB/CMYK pipeline under the hood rather than a native monochrome pipeline.
As a result, we have ended support for the XML driver beta. Jon felt it lacked the sophistication and was never intended to be a long-term solution, but rather a temporary bridge until QTR released support for newer printers - which it has now done.
Rachel,
I was using the XML driver because the Hybrid EvenTone dithering eliminated lines in my semi gloss prints. Using just QTR would be a lot easier printing. So a few questions. I’m using Epson 3880 and Epson P6000 printers with the Pro ink set.
Will I get the same quality of prints using QTR vs XML driver for Semi Gloss prints with the latest QTR updates.
Which dither would be best, or is just test and see.
I have both an Intel MacBook from 2015 that I set up for printing and a newer M5 MacBook.Which one would be best for printing. I know with the newest OS update I’m unable to use the XML driver on my M5.
Soft of unrelated I have a ColorMunki Photo but I only have software for Windows.Do you know of any software that will run on the Mac either Intel or Apple Silicon. I have not found anything on the internet. Help !
The Red River Aurora Natural paper is on the left and the Canson Arches 88 is on the right. To me there is a big difference in the print quality. The RR paper looks blotchy in the sky, the gradations are more course and the sharpness of lines is less with more random ink dots. This is not too bad in a print that is 8x10 but scale that up to a 24in print and the RR paper will be a mess. I strive to always get the best print possible. The RR paper does not absorb the ink like the Canson paper. The Canson paper is a beautiful bright white paper with no OBA’s. I do use the Red River Big Bend Baryta paper and it is on par with the look I get from Canson Baryta Photographique II. Lesson learned here is that sometimes trying to buy more economical paper, inks, etc is not worth the time or money.
Thanks for the great support I get from the Piezography team.
IJM is no longer providing support for the beta. You would have to do your own testing and draw your own conclusions whether you get the same quality or not. It seems that you have hardware issues if XML helped to mask it. It might be advantageous for you to remedy that so you can enjoy a normal QRT workflow.
QTR hasn’t drastically changed how it prints image pixels because its B&W dither and curve execution were already optimized. It has updated to ensure those same results can run on current operating systems and the newest supported Epson printer hardware. QTR remains the gold standard for this type of printing.
Keep the QTR dither set to Ordered (default). It is the algorithm around which almost all major fine-art B&W profile ecosystems (including Piezography, PiezoDN, and QuadToneProfiler) are built and calibrated.
Use your M5 for imaging, email, web browsing, AI, etc. As a printing system it is already becoming limited (settings for 3rd party PPDs) and OS X is deprecating CUPS. It is just a matter of time before QTR will become inoperable.
Use the 2015 as a printer server attaching your printers to it and sharing its screen to your M5. We have a tutorial on how to do that if you need. Because you are seeking to use your ColorMunki my understanding is that it did not progress past 32bit and you must keep your 2015 below Catalina in order to run it.
Many professional printing studios operate their printers with pre-Ventura OS X. Cone Editions Press which invented QuadBlack printing in the early 1990s and continues to develop Piezography is no exception.
Alternatively you can run the ColorMunki on Parallels for Desktop with Win 10 as it still supports 32 bit. Calibrite took over support for ColorMunki from x-Rite and they may have an upgrade for you. I took a peek on eBay and saw a ColorMunki with original CD for about $70. So you have lots of options.
Desktop RGB scanners do not resolve differences in dark tones in the same way a PMT drum scanner can. They are good enough for most people but not really good enough for the Piezography standard. This important shadow area has always been the limitation in converting RGB data to L*. The hard copy 2017 Piezography manual has a very short tutorial on scanning in combination with PiezoDN. But, we’ve not brought that forward as a supported method. Nothing replaces a spectro. The high cost is worth the results.
I have an i1 Photo version 2. This is our favored instrument.